Cheesy Keto Italian Meatballs: Super Yummy, Super Easy

I make no secret of the fact that I like easy recipes. But we’re also watching our eating habits and are working to keep our carbs low. This recipe for Cheesy Keto Italian Meatballs is easy and yummy…which is my favorite kind of dish.

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my full disclosure policy for details.

We love this recipe for Cheesy Keto Italian Meatballs just like it is. But I admit that I am a recipe “tweaker”. Now, if you’re a new cook, then follow the recipe exactly for known results. But here’s the thing about meatballs (and most recipes, to be honest), it’s hard to mess them up.

For example, if you’re not following a low carb diet and don’t necessarily have to have a Keto meatball, then you can substitute regular old bread crumbs for the almond flour. That will make the recipe cheaper (although definitely higher in carbs).

What DOES make a difference in this dish is the sauce that you serve the Keto Italian meatballs with. Jungle Jim has perfected the spice combination and while leaving something out won’t ruin the dish, it won’t be quite as tasty either.

With cooking it’s all about knowing what specific parts are critical to the recipe and which ones can be altered. Because cooking is always an experiment – you just get to eat the experiments.

What are the best kinds of meats to use for Keto meatballs?

You can use pretty much any kind of ground meat that you like. Our preferences run to hamburger or sausage, although ground turkey can make great meatballs as well. One of our favorites is a meatball made from equal parts hamburger and ground sausage. You can then add or reduce the spices you add depending on what flavor of sausage you used (we really like a hotter blend when we’re making meatballs but that’s just a personal preference.

Do you need any special equipment to make meatballs?

Nope. Just a willingness to get your hands dirty (after washing them, of course) by using them to “squish” the ingredients together.

Yes, you CAN use a spoon to stir everything together, but I find that using my hands results in a mixture that is more evenly mixed together. And while you can use a scoop to make your meatballs, it’s not necessary. Although it you’ve got a scoop you use for ice cream there’s certainly nothing wrong with using it if you don’t like getting your hands dirty (Jungle Jim always has me mix the meatballs and form them because he despises getting the mixture all over his hands – we’ve all got our quirks, right?)

How do I know when the meatballs are done?

Meatballs don’t take a long time to cook since they’re smaller chunks of meat. You can always use a meat thermometer to test the internal temperature (and I do recommend that every kitchen has a meat thermometer) or you can just eye-ball it. When the meat looks good and cooked on the outside, you can cut into one slightly to take a peek at the inside. You want to be sure that the inside is thoroughly cooked so that no one gets sick and because your meatballs are just going to have a better flavor when they’re completely done.

When in doubt, use the meat thermometer! And of course, the bigger the meatball, the longer the cooking time.

How should I cook meatballs?

One of the lovely thing about meatballs is that they can be cooked in a variety of ways.

We generally cook ours in a skillet, but they can also be cooked in a kettle in a sauce and they can be baked in the oven.

Print Recipe

More tasty – and easy – recipes for you to try

What if i hate planning meals?

I’m a huge advocate of meal planning. I think it’s one of the best ways to save money at the grocery store because you know what you’re going to cook and you don’t end up buying food that goes to waste.

But let’s be honest…if you know you’re someone who is not going to sit down and plan out your menus, there are other ways to skin this cat. There are subscription services that will let you select the kind of meals you like and will send you the weekly meal plan, recipes, and shopping list.

One of those is Meal Planning Central. It’s an affordable service and you can get your first week FREE to try it out to see what you think. If you decide to continue then it costs between $4 – $9 a month depending on the plan you choose. Yes, it’s an expense, but it’s pretty darn cheap when you consider the time you’ll save and that you won’t be wondering what to fix for dinner every night.